Monday, June 21, 2010

Detz' statement at school board

Here is a copy of Vern Detz' written statement read at Thursday's school board meeting:

For the 3 plus years that I’ve been attending Columbia Borough School Board meetings, I’ve heard on numerous occasions that it’s all about the kids! Truth be told, it should be all about the students of Columbia Borough School District. However, I have a hard time believing that to be the case when I see the decisions made by this Board over the last three years.
Anytime you talk of tightening your belts, it’s a cut to the education programs for these students you’re supposedly here to serve. It’s a cut to the Curriculum budget or a cut to the Extra Curricular budget or the talk of pay to play sports, where does it stop when it comes to OUR students? The lack of funding for Special Education is the reason given for the ever increasing taxes and while we may be under-funded for Special Education, there are other things under our control that would help our economic situation.
The one thing that I’ve NEVER heard discussed except by me when I stood at the podium and addressed the Board, is the “freezing” of wages or the cutting of positions for our Administrators, Teachers or Support Staff. In fact, we’re going to take action tonight on administrative raises which when passed, will be the 2nd increase in 6 months for these administrators. We’re living through the worse economy the United States has ever known and social security didn’t receive a raise, but we’re willing to give our administration a second raise in 6 months time and this will continue for the next 3 years. When this action is approved tonight, the cost of this administration for a student body of 570 students in grades 7-12 will be $895,697 in salaries without Dr. Clippinger's salary accounted for until August, which, when added in, will put us over $1 million in salaries alone, throw in their benefit package and the costs soar even higher.
I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, this is tax money leaving the Borough with very little if any of it being spent in Columbia as none of these administrators live in Columbia Borough. The salaries and wages that were negotiated in the last teachers contract by the previous Board giving 3.5-3.8% raises over the life of the contract and the proposed 3-3.5% for the support staff will continue to add to our economic challenges as a District. WHY do these contract have to be for 4 or 5 years, WHY can’t the employee be evaluated and given a fair raise every year instead of knowing that they’ll get their automatic, very generous raise every year.
The private sector has taken drastic steps to compete, including freezing or reducing wages, having employees pay for a large portion of their benefits and cutting the number of hours employees work in a week, it’s time the public sector does the same.
There are those who are making the tough decisions, Mayor Bloomberg has frozen wages for teachers and principals in NYC; the School District of Lancaster is cutting positions and a Superintendent in Montabella, Michigan who has been with the District for 40 years offered to work for free.(His salary is $95820 and the District refused, saying they’ll pay him something.) Expected savings will be $80-85k

We continue to burden our taxpayers with the rising costs of these salaries, well, it’s time we ask the administration, staff and teachers of the Columbia Borough School District to give something back instead of taking more and more.
We’ve got to look at Columbia Borough for what it is, a landlocked community with a diminishing tax base with little room for growth and stop trying to keep up with neighboring school districts. A number of taxpayers in this Borough who have worked their whole lives to own a home simply cannot afford a tax increase of any size without making the hard decision of whether they will have food on their table, the lights on in their house or even a roof over their heads.
I will be voting NO on the budget containing the 1.013 mill increase.

13 comments:

Anonymous said...

So, Mr. Detz, I guess you have turned down all the raises your company has offered to help the economy?

Anonymous said...

I am not a big fan of Mr Detz...but he is not so far off base with his statement. How much adminisration does a small school district need? As for turning down pay raises...my company has frozen raises and stop contributing to employee 401k. I believe that teacher unions are going to be destruction of our economy in PA...not just Columbia.

Anonymous said...

I totally agree with Mr. Detz. Thank you so much Vern for having the students future in mind rather than the administrators . Our children have had a tough yr. with all the construction . no local paper to applaud their many achievments etc. etc,. Thank you for having the guts to stand up for what most Columbians believe in .but are to apethetic to say ...... well done Vern Detz.
. .

Anonymous said...

For 180 days worth of work, teachers are paid pretty darn good. Yes, we all would take a raise if our companies were handing it out but this small town can't afford it. Not forever, just not right now. Society has become filled with a sense of entitlements. How many teachers are mediocre?!?! A heck of a lot. Much of the private sector provides raises based on merit...not schools. If you suck and have reached tenure, you have a job for life! That's the pathetic part. And not only have a job, but you get a raise for being lousy! Mr. Detz may have a raw way of saying it but he says is not pulling the wool over anyone's eyes! When are the people of this town and this country going to take back control and do the right thing for once, not just jump on board with the majority vote? Our children's futures are what's at stake. Everyone is too darn worried about their own pocketbook to see the BIG picture! Do the right thing for once! I am ready to board the bus to Harrisburg! How about you?!?!

Anonymous said...

I thought Mr. Detz was grandstanding all this time. Now I almost feel as though I owe him an apology. I started to follow what he was saying and started to look into it myself. This School district is in trouble.....I'm sorry I mean the property owners. I know one person that has to fork out $415.00 a month to meet their School taxes. Some would say including the School Finance Manager if you can't afford it downsize. The cost of living and health care costs have been going up. Employers are freezing raises as well. The short term outlook cannot be promising.

Anonymous said...

i am from columbia but can not afford to live in the borough becuase next to christiana borough, columbia has the highest school mills in the county. at least christiana borough is a farming community and has a liable excuse as to why their mills are so high. the school does nothing to help themselves in their own financial woes. the school listened to an over paid, under qualified landscaper in the name of Mike Miller and decided to half ass the major reconstruction of their football sports complex. putting turf down on the football field not only would have saved cost through mowing grass, re-sodding the field, watering, painting, ect, it would have brought added money to the school by hosting field hockey, soccer and laccross playoff games. Miller on the otherhand decided it would be best to keep grass, and burn money. I also noticed they put a six lane track down instead of eight (there is eight lanes on the straight-a-way though). this 6 lane track now takes the school out of contention for hosting track invitationals, leagues or districts, ALSO money to the school. No regulation baseball or softball fields, again- lost money for hosting games. Final point of everything- you say cut salaries of teachers, but you want the best for your children, think of it this way- when you (the person reading this) are looking for a job, would you go to a place that is paying little, with a bad reputation, or a place that is paying a decent wage? quality teachers will not stay, or come to CHS, if they do, they will be right out of college, stay 1-3 years and leave. the turnover rate will be tremendous and your children will reap the "benefits".

Anonymous said...

I have to agree with the poswt about Mr. Miller. This has been going on for a number of years and no one stops him. Columbia could host invitationals in track. What to know there's no "fake" grass, look at the Taj Mahal admin center. It was a gift filled with asbestos and the school district didn't know about it. Columbia could have purchased the land near Taylor Elementary School on Ninth Street, bit thought they were getting something free. The field because of what was mentioned above and our location would have paid for itself by now, but Mr. Miller burned out the field by the first game. As for softball, back in the 1990s, Columbia did host District 3 and PIAA playoffs at Glatfelter and those fields are better than some the girls play on. And this guy makes 78,000 and has probably cost the school district that much if not more.

Anonymous said...

THANK YOU VERN!!!!!!!!

I am tired of breaking my back to support these teachers incomes today, tomorrow and making sure they get all but the same pay when they retire!!! We can no longer support these teachers lifestyles the way they want to be supported. Get rid of them and many of those recent college grads who are working for minimum wage will work for $12/hour, plus healthcare benefits that cost $35/week for individuals, $70 for family and a standard 401K plan. Forgot to mention those performance based raises during annual reviews too!!

Anonymous said...

Special Education Director Jennifer Zolenas-West reported at last Thursday's meeting, that 56 students moved into the school district within the past year, many needing special education services.

What is the school doing about this issue? I wonder how many of these "special needs" students actually live in Columbia. I heard the school board president say several years ago that many of the special needs students don't even live in Columbia. That Columbia has such a good program for these students that parents are listing a Columbia addres when in fact they do not even live in Columbia. Why doesn't the school look into hiring someone to go around and physically check on the residency of ALL of our students? It costs 3 times more to educate these students than the ones that are not special needs. I wonder just what percent of our student body is considered special needs?

RiverCouple735 said...

Thanks Vern for having the courage to take a stand!

Anonymous said...

Ditto

Anonymous said...

Anoymous....it isnt about the economy its about the kids...get with the program!!!

Anonymous said...

I agree 100%. The problem is the kids aren't getting what the should! Have you checked the latest PSSA scores? Columbia does pretty poorly.

http://www.ydr.com/ci_13258239?source=most_viewed&appSession=151615841871036